Western Balkans citizens legally resident in EU equal to 14% of region’s population
International Ice Hockey Federation (IIHF) has stripped Belarus of the right to hold the World Championship this year
Alexei Navalny arrested on arrival as he returns home
LONG READ: The oligarch problem
Consumer confidence index drops q/q, y/y in 4Q20
M&A in Central and Eastern Europe fell 16% in value in 2020, says CMS report
Russia’s grain harvest may fall to 131mn tonnes in 2021 from 133mn tonnes in 2020
ING: Russia balance of payments: supportive of ruble in the near-term, but risks for 2H21 mount.
Western Balkans and Ukraine urged to scrutinise coal subsidies
Oligarchs trying to derail Ukraine’s privatisation programme, warns the head of Ukraine’s State Property Fund
Private finance mobilised by development banks up 9% to $175bn in 2019
VISEGRAD BLOG: Central Europe's populists need a new strategy for Biden
OUTLOOK 2021 Lithuania
EBRD says loan to Estonia’s controversial Porto Franco project was never disbursed
Czech Pirates and Mayors approve final coalition agreement for 2021 elections
Hungarian vehicle makers hit by supply chain shortage
COVID-19 and Trump’s indifference helped human rights abusers in 2020
OUTLOOK 2021 Poland
OUTLOOK 2021 Slovakia
BRICKS & MORTAR: Rosier future beckons for CEE retailers after year of change and disruption
FDI inflows to CEE down 58% in 1H20 but rebound expected
BALKAN BLOG: US approach to switch from quick-fix dealmaking to experience and cooperation
Corona-induced slump in global clothing sector dragged down Albania’s 2020 exports
BALKAN BLOG: The controversial recipe for building up Albania
Turnover rose on Bosnia's two stock exchanges in 2020 while prices fell
Bulgaria’s government considers gradual easing of COVID-related restrictions
Sofia-based LAUNCHub Ventures holds first close of new fund on €44mn
ING: Growth in the Balkans: from zero to hero again?
Spring lockdown caused spike in online transactions in Croatia
Labour demand down 28% y/y in Croatia in 2020
EBRD investments reach record €11bn in pandemic-struck 2020
OUTLOOK 2021 Moldova
Storming parliaments: New Europe's greatest hits
World Bank revises projection for Moldova’s 2020 GDP decline to 7.2%
Montenegrins say state administration is most corrupt institution
North Macedonia plans to cut personal income tax in IT sector to zero in 2023
OUTLOOK 2021 Romania
Romania’s central bank cuts monetary policy rate by 25bp to 1.25%
OUTLOOK 2021 Slovenia
Slovenia’s opposition files no-confidence motion against Jansa cabinet
Slovenia’s government to release funds to news agency STA after EU pressure
UK Moneyhub picks Slovenia for post-Brexit European base
Turkey’s benchmark rate held as concerns over faltering recovery come to fore
Turkish lira breaches HSBC’s stop-loss, Turkey ETF signalling outflows
ISTANBUL BLOG: Biden must find a way to work with Trump’s strongman pal Erdogan
CAUCASUS BLOG : What can Biden offer the Caucasus and Stans, all but forgotten about by Trump?
Armenia ‘to extend life of its 1970s Metsamor nuclear power plant after 2026’
OUTLOOK 2021 Armenia
COMMENT: Record high debt levels will slow post-coronavirus recovery, threaten some countries' financial stability, says IIF
OUTLOOK 2021 Georgia
Iran’s technology minister indicted for failing to properly implement internet censorship
No US move to rejoin Iran nuclear deal imminent say Biden national security nominees
TEHRAN BLOG: Will Biden bet on a quick return to the Iran nuclear deal?
Tehran Stock Exchange chief quits amid “Black Monday” fury
Central Asia vaccination plans underwhelm, but governments look unruffled
Fears of authoritarianism as Kyrgyz populist wins landslide and backing for ‘Khanstitution’
Mongolia's winter dzud set to be one of most extreme on record says Red Cross
Mongolian coal exports to China paralysed as Beijing demands virus testing of truck drivers
Mongolia fears economic damage as country faces up to its first local transmissions of coronavirus
Mongolia in lockdown after suffering first local coronavirus transmissions
OUTLOOK 2021 Tajikistan
OUTLOOK 2021 Turkmenistan
Turkmenistan: How the Grinch stole New Year
COMMENT: Uzbekistan is being transformed, but where are the democratic reforms?
Download the pdf version
The coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic that struck the world this year has resulted in an increase in the role of the state as governments were forced to step in with emergency stimulus packages, support for people and companies whose incomes were hit by the spring lockdowns and a ramping up of funding for healthcare.
The latest annual Transition Report from the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD), titled “The state strikes back”, shows that the pandemic has encouraged people to see an increased role for the state in a more positive light. 45% of people in the post-communist states now favour higher levels of state ownership, says the EBRD’s chief economist, Beata Javorcik, in an interview with bne IntelliNews. Moreover, people who come of age during an epidemic are more likely to support public ownership and to be suspicious of the market economy.
The more positive view of an increase in the state’s role in the economy is not purely a product of the coronavirus pandemic, however. This year’s public health crisis accelerated but did not create the phenomenon.
“When the EBRD published its first Transition Report back in 1994, the prevailing consensus was that lower levels of state ownership helped to create more dynamic and prosperous economies … Today, there is a sense that the state is striking back,” says the report.
“And that was true even before the arrival of COVID-19. In advanced economies, more firms were nationalised than privatised in the early years of the 21st century, while economies where state ownership is widespread, such as China and Singapore, have experienced exceptional rates of economic growth. Household surveys reveal significant and rising support for the expansion of state ownership, perhaps as a reflection of rising inequality and the scars of the global financial crisis of 2008-09.”
This could see a reversal of trends over the past decades. State employment declined in both advanced economies and emerging markets, and even faster in the EBRD region, from 45% in the mid-1990s to 24% in the mid-2010s – a change attributed both to privatisation and more vibrant entrepreneurial activity.
However, since the international economic crisis, state employment has been increasing in many lower income economies. In around one third of the EBRD region, the public sector share of employment rose between 2015 and 2018, especially in four Eurasian countries, Armenia, Georgia, Kazakhstan and Mongolia.
Despite decades of privatisations, “state-owned enterprises continue to play an important role in the EBRD regions, providing almost half of all public-sector employment”, concentrated in the energy, utilities and transport sectors, according to the report.
A question of governance
The role of state-owned enterprises as a stabilising force – for example, providing employment during downturns and in disadvantaged regions – was clear in spring 2020, when state-owned enterprise (SOE) employees were less likely to have their pay cut when lockdowns brought a halt to much economic activity.
However, Javorcik warns in an interview with bne IntelliNews that an expansion of the state role in the economy in countries with poor governance “is a dangerous thing” because many SOEs are very poorly governed.
“In almost half of the counties where we operate, the same ministry is running the state-owned enterprise and regulating the sector; in one fifth it’s the state-owned enterprise itself that has the regulatory power. In the vast majority of countries there are no rules against state-owned enterprises receiving support from the state that would give them an advantage, for example getting subsided inputs like energy, water or land, getting preferential financing, preferential tax treatment or soft budget constraints. They may be transacting with other state-owned enterprises not on commercial terms, and that means that the playing field may be tilted against the private sector,” Javorcik explains.
As for the EBRD’s role, Javorcik believes the shift back towards greater state involvement in the economy means the bank “will be needed more than ever” as the issue of governance becomes more important now with the crisis and with growing support for state intervention. “We can help countries improve the regulatory framework of state-owned enterprises, help with running state-owned enterprises in terms of structure of the board.”
Asked whether the increase in the state’s role in the economy will be a permanent change that will persist post-pandemic, Javorcik says this will again depend on the level of governance. “In countries that are poorly governed, when the state takes over an enterprise this is an opportunity to give jobs to political supporters, to friends, so there is a danger that vested interests will be created that will prevent subsequent privatisation. The state-owned enterprise may stay in the same hands for a long time.”
Banks in state hands
Well before the start of the pandemic, state-owned banks had been growing in importance across the EBRD region since the mid-2000s, during which time they have expanded their assets almost twice as fast as private banks.
Belarus, Russia and Ukraine are among the emerging market economies where state banks own more than half of all banking assets. In Russia, state banks owned more than 60% of all banking assets in 2016-18. State ownership is relatively low in Central and Southeast Europe, where most banks were privatised in the early 1990s, though there too there has been an increase in state ownership of the sector in certain countries recently.
“The banking sector is perhaps the area where the state has struck back most clearly in recent years,” wrote Javorcik in the report.
This has turned state banks into “major competitors to the private sector”, not least, says the EBRD, “because many have less stringent lending standards, lower net interest rate margins and a higher tolerance of non-performing loans.”
During a crisis, state banks’ willingness to assume risks can help soften the impact of economic shocks. However, the companies that borrow from the state financial sector tend to be less innovative and show weaker productivity growth, says the EBRD, partly because state-owned banks can be more susceptible to political interference in their lending decisions.
Javorcik gives the example of Turkey – though similar actions have been observed in numerous other countries – where research quoted in the report has shown crediting directed in response to local election battles. State banks, says the report, have been pumping credit into provinces where elections are closely contested and the mayor represents the ruling party. Conversely, state banks have been shown to be withholding credit in areas where the mayor is from the opposition.
Systematically adjusting lending in response to local elections is problematic on two counts, as outlined by Javorcik. First, it is an abuse of political power. Second, it leads to inefficiency, because the banks are issuing loans to the wrong firms, which often leads to high default rates later on and foregoing economic growth.
The green future
Decisions made now – as governments are looking to the post-crisis recovery – are critical, wrote Javorcik in the foreword to the report.
“The economies of the EBRD regions stand at a crossroads, with decisions on policies and institutions that are taken now potentially determining their paths for decades to come. The current period of crisis and upheaval triggered by the global pandemic represents a valuable opportunity to lay the foundations for a wealthier, fairer and greener future,” wrote Javorcik.
The EBRD calls on countries in the region to “build the transition to a green economy into their post-COVID-19 recovery plans, prioritise industries and firms with a zero-carbon future, and not prop up “zombie firms that will struggle in the green economy”.
Unfortunately, finds the report, “EBRD economies are falling behind in the enforcement of policies that help reduce carbon emissions, in the wake of the 2015 Paris Agreement.” What has been achieved is a reduction in CO2 emissions by 12% over the period 1997-2016 relative to the levels that would otherwise have been seen. However, while they have set targets, the report says these are “not sufficiently ambitious”, and they are lagging on enforcement.
The report explores the role state-owned energy companies can play in the green transition in the region, and whether and how they can be used directly to support the transition to a green economy.
“The fact that in many of our countries the state-owned enterprises play quite a big role in the energy sector is an opportunity to use them to deal with stranded assets,” comments Javorcik.
However, achieving this will require action by governments. “It is clear … that if state ownership is to become a climate policy tool, policy action is required on the part of state enterprise owners – national governments,” says the report.
While private sector “ingenuity, investment and entrepreneurship” is needed for a successful green transition, “a strong state – encompassing sound public policy, strong state institutions and determined political leadership – is needed to channel private-sector dynamism in the right direction”, says the report. Specifically, states need to “incentivise companies and consumers to think green, promote clean investment and remove barriers preventing a smooth transition to the low-carbon economy of the future”.
There are fears the green transition will be particularly painful in parts of the region that still rely heavily on coal for power generation and where the coal industry is the main employer. Javorcik points out that in Poland, more than 1% of employment is in the coal sector, directly and indirectly.
Outlining the EBRD’s approach, she says: “We want to protect workers, not jobs. We want to take care of people… but we can’t try to keep the structure of the economy. The world has changed and the world will be changing as carbon prices go up.”
According to Javorcik the pandemic has changed perceptions of climate change in the bank’s region of operations. The EBRD ran a survey in August asking respondents whether they had become more concerned about climate change as a result of COVID-19.
“The result was striking,” Javorcik tells bne IntelliNews. “COVID-19 is changing perceptions.”
Over half of the respondents in Turkey said yes, as did more than 40% in Greece and Egypt and one third in Poland. Javorcik hones in on the impact of the crisis on young people from the Eastern Europe region, whose international mobility has abruptly been curtailed (and may be further restricted by Brexit).
“Young people will be paying off the debt of COVID-19, young people will be dealing with the consequences of climate change. If they stay [in Central and Eastern Europe] and become more politically active they have a chance of changing the political discourse. Growing awareness of climate change combined with the activation of young people could lead changes.”
here to continue reading this article
and 5 more for free or purchase
12 months full website access including
the bne Magazine for just $250/year.
Register to read the bne monthly magazine for
Password could contain only
and have 8-20 symbols length.
Please complete your registration by confirming your
A confirmation email has been sent to the email
address you provided.
can't be empty.
No user with
this email address.
Access recovery request has expired, or you are using
the wrong recovery token. Please, try again.
Access recover request has expired.
Please, try again.
To continue viewing our content you need to complete
the registration process.
Please look for an email that was sent to
with the subject line
"Confirmation bne IntelliNews access". This email will have
instructions on how to complete registration
process. Please check in your "Junk" folder in
case this communication was misdirected in your
If you have any questions please contact us at email@example.com
Sorry, but you have used all your free articles fro
this month for bne IntelliNews. Subscribe
to continue reading for only $119 per year.
Your subscription includes:
For the meantime we are also offering a free
digital weekly newspaper to subscribers to
the online package.
Click here for more subscription options,
including to the print version of our
flagship monthly magazine:
Take a trial to our premium daily news
service aimed at professional investors that
covers the 30 countries of emerging
For any other enquiries about our
products or corporate discounts please
contact us at
If you no longer wish to receive
Magazine annual print
Website & Archive
Combined package: web
access & magazine print
Take a trial to our premium daily news service
aimed at professional investors that
covers the 30 countries of emerging Europe: